16 January 2011

Wrapping Up the 2010-11 Season

Another great season of college football wraps up and it's time for me to go into blog hibernation until the spring games or, more likely, summer pre-season poll discussions. But here is a quick run down of some of the seasons high and low-lights.

We saw it all in this season of changes, scandals, continued BCS whining, etc. etc. From the late summer conference shifts to...
...BYU going independent
...VaTech high-tech unis on labor day (but lost)
...AJ Green 4-game suspension for selling jersey
...VaTech losing again in Week #2 to James-Madison
...Top 25 newbies Nevada and Mississippi State and UCF
...the grass-eating Mad Hatter
...Boise or TCU
...the little sisters of the poor
...the Nevada win over Boise
...the pay-for-play Newton scandal
...Meyer retirement (Part II)
...un-ranked UConn going to a BCS bowl
...VaTech going to a BCS bowl after loss to FCS
...the Tattoo U (Ohio State) non-suspension for bowl game
...two C-USA teams in the Top 25
...the championship game match-up
...the unprecedented five consecutive championships by the SEC
...and back-to-back champions who also had the Heisman winners
...and back-to-back champions from the same state
...and the championship game being the most watched cable show in history. Whew!

PS: Hey...did anyone really miss USC in the post-season? (Well, I missed seeing the cheerleaders).

EndZone: The College Football Scam
You've heard be whine before about the face of college football moving away from tradition and closer to money, money, money for the BCS, schools, coaches, etc. The Cam Newton saga showed the player side of that this past season. Cam has been amazing on and off the field and it is sad that he has had to deal with so much the last few months that has taken away from his amazing athletic ability. Rules are there for a reason...for protection. But I'll be the first to say the the NCAA has quite the scam when it comes to college football: high-priced tickets, willing sponsors, huge audience and your stars don't get paid...much. Dan Wetzel's article said it well.

"What are all these rules? Who made them? Who agreed to them? Who is the NCAA? And if the NCAA doesn’t care to enforce its own rules, then what are they really worth?

Exactly why should Cam Newton, who is worth millions to a university, whose jersey is being sold all over the school website, who fills stadiums and boosts television ratings, be asked to play football for just room, board and tuition – an amount far below his market value?

Why? Because the NCAA says he should.

They say it, in part, because it protects college athletics’ tax-free status and tradition of non-compensation for its meal-ticket athletes. It funds their salaries, their private jets, their six-figure bonuses.

Big-time college sports are too often like pro wrestling. There are times everyone has to pretend that things are what they aren’t.

They have to agree that this billion-dollar industry is just an extracurricular activity of an institute of higher learning. They have to claim the game is pure in the face of wealthy boosters, eager sports agents and all-encompassing academic tutors. They have to nod approval at multimillion-dollar coach and athletic director contracts.

They have to contend that administrators are concerned with the best interests of the players – the same players they deny professional representation, do not provide lifetime health care for after serious injury and claim ownership of their likeness even decades after leaving campus.

To assist in the illusion, the NCAA creates rules, even if, at times, they don’t appear to believe in them. It determined Cecil violated its bylaw 12.3.3. It then determined that it merited essentially no penalty.

11 January 2011

Bowl Commentary (03-10 Jan 2011)

Comments on the final bowls of the season. The Orange showcased some amazing talent, the Sugar was down to the wire and the championship game shined best of all.

Orange Bowl
Really? VaTech lost to James-Madison? They looked quite the team...in the first half. But Stanford made the adjustments at half-time and VaTech didn't. Luck was amazing, accurate and poised.

Sugar Bowl
Really? Arkansas let this slip away in the end when they had it all but handed to them. Though I'm not a fan of the Big 10 I was impressed with their talented receivers and even the fully and free tattooed Pryor.

Cotton Bowl
Though I have spouted all season that LSU has been lucky I still like to watch them play. I like their aggressive and surprising play calling...and it paid of once again. Did you notice that they never showed Texas A&M cheerleaders but they did show LSU cheerleaders? That's because Texas A&M does not have cheerleaders...and never has! See article here.

Fight Hunger
Nevada did not dominate as I expected but they made a good showing and pulled off the win. And I don't think they are a flash-in-the-pan. There will be more to be seen from that program int eh next few years.

BCS Championship
Wow...if any game lived up to its billing this one did. Much like the USC-Texas championship in 2006 - but a whole lot better. Both defenses were very well prepared; Newton and James did not perform as expected. Oregon had some great play calls (fake PAT, fake punt, deep pass from their own endzone, etc.) which showed why UA ran down the clock before kicking the winning FG. The UA goal line stops of the high-powered Oregon offense were near un-believable.

02 January 2011

Bowl Commentary (thru 01 Jan 2011)

A few comments on the bulk of the 28-day, 35-game bowl season. A few surprises, some boring bowls, and, some of the best I've seen. Currently the Sun Belt has the best conference bowl record (2-0, 100%) followed by the MWC at 4-1. The current bottom dweller is the "Bog-10" at 2-5...with all five losses coming on New Year's Day. Sometimes the Big-10 isn't so big after all.

New Mexico Bowl
BYU looked refined and already geared up for next season. Looks like the independence thing just might work.
MAACO Bowl
As I expected...Boise dominated and exposed (again) a very over-rated Utah team. Give the Utes credit for a very good defense the first quarter but Boise made the adjustments and Utah didn't.
Poinsettia
San Diego looks like a team on the move upward. Talented and fast receivers and a powerful running back made up for any lack of defense.
Independence
Gotta give the credit to AF against what I thought was a much better option team. But AF showed that if you pass when they don't think you will you can win.
Holiday Bowl
Probably the biggest surprise thus far. A standing ovation to Locker for going out on top. I've said it before and it's worth repeating: Sark has something good cooking up there in the wet north-west.
Liberty Bowl
Where was the UGA offense of their last six games? After the first series the players and coaches were about as aggressive and flat as a grade school girl. Although they graduated to a training bra size in the last minute it was too little too late. The MAC champions are for real and I expect to see more of them next year in both the polls and bowls.
Chick-fil-A Bowl
Ouch! Key players on both sides out in the first half made for an interesting game...and was likely the reason for the UScar loss.
Outback Bowl
Meyer goes out with a win, a well deserved win. Though I don't always agree with his off-the-field comments and whines I have never questioned his commitment to his teams nor his ability to coach. And, I admire and respect his decision to focus on family and health. Godspeed, Whiner Meyer.
Gator and Capital One Bowl
Finally the SEC lives up to its bowl expectations (after the UGA and SCar losses). No surprise since I have felt the Big 10 has been over-rated. 'Bama and Miss State outscore the Big 10 by 80 points, 101 to 21.
Rose Bowl
Wisconsin was better than I had expected...much better. They had an amazing run game against a great TCU defense. But TCU outlasted the heralded Badger QB and O-line...just barely
. Kudos to TCU for making a statement for all the little guys.
Fiesta Bowl
I boycotted the OU and UConn match-up since I did not agree with UConn playing this big money bowl over multiple 1-loss teams that truly earned and deserved the money. No comment.

23 December 2010

Bowl Season 2010: My Annual BCS Whine

OK...time for the BCS whine 2010 (and, no, I do't want any cheese with that). It's just a thing we fans do - something to go along with all the other NCAAF fodder. True, there is a lot of re-hashing but it's still fun. And hey, a few more years of all this whining and BCS bashing will pay off with a new system. Yes, I really believe that.

Funny
So did the BCS work this year? ESPN went so far as to say on 05 Dec (Bowl Selection day) that there was nothing to complain about this year...the "best match-up since USC-Texas". As far as the championship match-up, I agree. But if the system is so good why does it not work every year? And to say there is "nothing to complain about"? How about VaTech playing in a BCS bowl? Why do we allow the AQ teams who lost to a non-AQ team and an FBS team get the big payout? And how about un-ranked UConn? Why does an un-ranked, 8-4 team get the bid overany of the six 1-loss teams?

It's All About $Money$
This year the BCS bowls will pay out $18MM each while at the other end of the spectrum the New Orleans Bowl will pay out $500,000. Keep the rich rich and poor poor. The problem with that mindset is you will always have a Cinderella team and a "I'll show you" team (ie: TCU, Utah and Boise State). And thank heaven for those teams who have provided just enough to help push the BCS system out. Will it all change now that TCU and Utah are moving to AQ conferences? No - there will always be a non-AQ team reducing the number of BCS proponents and making the remainder find it harder and harder to stand up for the big money and inequalities.

From Dan Wetzel, 24 Nov 2010 (click here to see full article)
"In truth, the BCS isn’t about crowning a champion in college football, it was just a tool created so private bowl games could continue to operate (and profit handsomely from) college football’s postseason. By further entrenching themselves as the postseason operators, bowls continue to take hundreds of millions annually from the pockets of actual colleges. This is why no other sport would allow such a set up. What business outsources its most important and profitable product? The BCS is about protecting the profits of bowl games and nothing else. It’s about money, money and only money. It’s why the BCS employs PR people, Washington lobbyists and multiple law firms to maintain the status quo and create water muddying arguments."

EndZone
Save us Mark Cuban! Mark has so much money he has resorted to fixing college football...literally considering buying the fix for the college football championship argument. Clickhere and here.

05 December 2010

Week 14: Regular Season Wrap-Up

The fat lady is warming up for the bowl season...the games are all wrapped up...Cam is ready to receive the bronze trophy next week...the bowls are all set. It's been a great season and here are a few season finale comments....

Any surprise about the final #1 and #2? Well, not since a month or two ago but remember that Auburn and Oregon were pre-season (AP) at un-ranked and #11. It is the right match-up for the championship and I think it will be one of the best ever... reminiscent of the 2005 Texas - USC match-up.

And what about the other pre-season picks? Where are they now? Miami, Iowa, Pittsburgh, Florida, Texas? Wow - there were some serious college kids' dreams shattered over the last few months.

And who'd have thought: Nevada in the top 20? And Hawaii back in the top 25? Mississippi State and UCF? Was anyone even thinking about them four months ago? Some dreams come true.

EndZone
Big, big kudos to Sarkisian for getting UW and Jake Locker to a well-deserved bowl game - their first since 2002. That program is in a big-time, impressive turn-around and will have to be reckoned with in the new PAC-12.

PS: My annual BCS rant is on the editor's desk and will be posted next week.